mirror of
https://github.com/torvalds/linux.git
synced 2026-05-16 02:25:58 +02:00
754aa6427e
There is an smp_mb() named "E" in srcu_flip() immediately before the
increment (flip) of the srcu_struct structure's ->srcu_idx.
The purpose of E is to order the preceding scan's read of lock counters
against the flipping of the ->srcu_idx, in order to prevent new readers
from continuing to use the old ->srcu_idx value, which might needlessly
extend the grace period.
However, this ordering is already enforced because of the control
dependency between the preceding scan and the ->srcu_idx flip.
This control dependency exists because atomic_long_read() is used
to scan the counts, because WRITE_ONCE() is used to flip ->srcu_idx,
and because ->srcu_idx is not flipped until the ->srcu_lock_count[] and
->srcu_unlock_count[] counts match. And such a match cannot happen when
there is an in-flight reader that started before the flip (observation
courtesy Mathieu Desnoyers).
The litmus test below (courtesy of Frederic Weisbecker, with changes
for ctrldep by Boqun and Joel) shows this:
C srcu
(*
* bad condition: P0's first scan (SCAN1) saw P1's idx=0 LOCK count inc, though P1 saw flip.
*
* So basically, the ->po ordering on both P0 and P1 is enforced via ->ppo
* (control deps) on both sides, and both P0 and P1 are interconnected by ->rf
* relations. Combining the ->ppo with ->rf, a cycle is impossible.
*)
{}
// updater
P0(int *IDX, int *LOCK0, int *UNLOCK0, int *LOCK1, int *UNLOCK1)
{
int lock1;
int unlock1;
int lock0;
int unlock0;
// SCAN1
unlock1 = READ_ONCE(*UNLOCK1);
smp_mb(); // A
lock1 = READ_ONCE(*LOCK1);
// FLIP
if (lock1 == unlock1) { // Control dep
smp_mb(); // E // Remove E and still passes.
WRITE_ONCE(*IDX, 1);
smp_mb(); // D
// SCAN2
unlock0 = READ_ONCE(*UNLOCK0);
smp_mb(); // A
lock0 = READ_ONCE(*LOCK0);
}
}
// reader
P1(int *IDX, int *LOCK0, int *UNLOCK0, int *LOCK1, int *UNLOCK1)
{
int tmp;
int idx1;
int idx2;
// 1st reader
idx1 = READ_ONCE(*IDX);
if (idx1 == 0) { // Control dep
tmp = READ_ONCE(*LOCK0);
WRITE_ONCE(*LOCK0, tmp + 1);
smp_mb(); /* B and C */
tmp = READ_ONCE(*UNLOCK0);
WRITE_ONCE(*UNLOCK0, tmp + 1);
} else {
tmp = READ_ONCE(*LOCK1);
WRITE_ONCE(*LOCK1, tmp + 1);
smp_mb(); /* B and C */
tmp = READ_ONCE(*UNLOCK1);
WRITE_ONCE(*UNLOCK1, tmp + 1);
}
}
exists (0:lock1=1 /\ 1:idx1=1)
More complicated litmus tests with multiple SRCU readers also show that
memory barrier E is not needed.
This commit therefore clarifies the comment on memory barrier E.
Why not also remove that redundant smp_mb()?
Because control dependencies are quite fragile due to their not being
recognized by most compilers and tools. Control dependencies therefore
exact an ongoing maintenance burden, and such a burden cannot be justified
in this slowpath. Therefore, that smp_mb() stays until such time as
its overhead becomes a measurable problem in a real workload running on
a real production system, or until such time as compilers start paying
attention to this sort of control dependency.
Co-developed-by: Frederic Weisbecker <frederic@kernel.org>
Signed-off-by: Frederic Weisbecker <frederic@kernel.org>
Co-developed-by: Mathieu Desnoyers <mathieu.desnoyers@efficios.com>
Signed-off-by: Mathieu Desnoyers <mathieu.desnoyers@efficios.com>
Co-developed-by: Boqun Feng <boqun.feng@gmail.com>
Signed-off-by: Boqun Feng <boqun.feng@gmail.com>
Reviewed-by: Paul E. McKenney <paulmck@kernel.org>
Signed-off-by: Joel Fernandes (Google) <joel@joelfernandes.org>
|
||
|---|---|---|
| .. | ||
| bpf | ||
| cgroup | ||
| configs | ||
| debug | ||
| dma | ||
| entry | ||
| events | ||
| futex | ||
| gcov | ||
| irq | ||
| kcsan | ||
| livepatch | ||
| locking | ||
| module | ||
| power | ||
| printk | ||
| rcu | ||
| sched | ||
| time | ||
| trace | ||
| .gitignore | ||
| acct.c | ||
| async.c | ||
| audit_fsnotify.c | ||
| audit_tree.c | ||
| audit_watch.c | ||
| audit.c | ||
| audit.h | ||
| auditfilter.c | ||
| auditsc.c | ||
| backtracetest.c | ||
| bounds.c | ||
| capability.c | ||
| cfi.c | ||
| compat.c | ||
| configs.c | ||
| context_tracking.c | ||
| cpu_pm.c | ||
| cpu.c | ||
| crash_core.c | ||
| crash_dump.c | ||
| cred.c | ||
| delayacct.c | ||
| dma.c | ||
| exec_domain.c | ||
| exit.c | ||
| extable.c | ||
| fail_function.c | ||
| fork.c | ||
| freezer.c | ||
| gen_kheaders.sh | ||
| groups.c | ||
| hung_task.c | ||
| iomem.c | ||
| irq_work.c | ||
| jump_label.c | ||
| kallsyms_internal.h | ||
| kallsyms_selftest.c | ||
| kallsyms_selftest.h | ||
| kallsyms.c | ||
| kcmp.c | ||
| Kconfig.freezer | ||
| Kconfig.hz | ||
| Kconfig.locks | ||
| Kconfig.preempt | ||
| kcov.c | ||
| kexec_core.c | ||
| kexec_elf.c | ||
| kexec_file.c | ||
| kexec_internal.h | ||
| kexec.c | ||
| kheaders.c | ||
| kmod.c | ||
| kprobes.c | ||
| ksysfs.c | ||
| kthread.c | ||
| latencytop.c | ||
| Makefile | ||
| module_signature.c | ||
| notifier.c | ||
| nsproxy.c | ||
| padata.c | ||
| panic.c | ||
| params.c | ||
| pid_namespace.c | ||
| pid_sysctl.h | ||
| pid.c | ||
| profile.c | ||
| ptrace.c | ||
| range.c | ||
| reboot.c | ||
| regset.c | ||
| relay.c | ||
| resource_kunit.c | ||
| resource.c | ||
| rseq.c | ||
| scftorture.c | ||
| scs.c | ||
| seccomp.c | ||
| signal.c | ||
| smp.c | ||
| smpboot.c | ||
| smpboot.h | ||
| softirq.c | ||
| stackleak.c | ||
| stacktrace.c | ||
| static_call_inline.c | ||
| static_call.c | ||
| stop_machine.c | ||
| sys_ni.c | ||
| sys.c | ||
| sysctl-test.c | ||
| sysctl.c | ||
| task_work.c | ||
| taskstats.c | ||
| torture.c | ||
| tracepoint.c | ||
| tsacct.c | ||
| ucount.c | ||
| uid16.c | ||
| uid16.h | ||
| umh.c | ||
| up.c | ||
| user_namespace.c | ||
| user-return-notifier.c | ||
| user.c | ||
| usermode_driver.c | ||
| utsname_sysctl.c | ||
| utsname.c | ||
| watch_queue.c | ||
| watchdog_hld.c | ||
| watchdog.c | ||
| workqueue_internal.h | ||
| workqueue.c | ||